I guess I’m just a masochist

Last night I attended the monthly meeting of the Ottawa Canada Linux Users Group (OCLUG). While I am technically a member and have been since about 2000, unfortunately I rarely get to go because of other commitments on Tuesday nights. Much of the time the presentations are of a highly technical nature and actually hold little interest for me, as I’m more or less an end-user rather than a hacker.

But last night’s meeting was worthwhile for the opening presentation, given by Josh Bush, one of the organizers of linux.conf.au, Australia and New Zealand’s annual Linux conference held last month in Hobart, Tasmania. In particular, Josh handed around a copy of the conference program. It was done entirely with open-source software: Gimp and Inkscape for the graphics, OpenOffice for the text, and Scribus to put it all together. It was slick: glossy, four-colour, spiral-bound, and all round quite professional.

I’ve got Scribus installed, and after seeing what it is actually capable of, today I felt inspired to give it a spin. So I located a sample text (one of my old Sunday school lessons), gave it a quick massage in OpenOffice, and fired up Scribus to have some fun. Or so I hoped.

  • After a quick page setup, I tried to import my OpenOffice exemplar. “Scribus crashes due to Signal #11.” Total user experience to date: 5 seconds. Feh.
  • Take two: maybe the first crash was a freak occurrence. But this time, before attempting the import, I saved all my settings. Another “Signal #11.” Double feh. But, when I reloaded my Scribus document, I found out it had somehow imported the text anyway. Go figure. Well, at least it saved me the trouble of launching OpenOffice again just for the sake of a quick cut-and-paste.
  • The import completely strips all formatting from the text – including bold or italicized words. So now I will have to go through the whole thing and fix them manually.
  • Except that apparently the programmers never saw fit to include a “bold” or “italic” feature. You can work around it by highlighting the word and changing the font to the italic or bold version, but still.
  • Next step: Create some paragraph styles so I can format the text. Well, isn’t that interesting? It appears that the developers who coded the left-margin-indent feature didn’t think someone might need to indent the right margin as well.
  • Then I set up some master pages, with appropriate headers and footers and margins for left and right printing. Turns out that applying a new master page over an existing page isn’t the cleanest operation.
  • Next, I created enough pages to hold all the text (about 10) and began linking them together so the text would flow properly from page to page. Oops, missed one. Unlink, unlink, unlink, unlink, unlink . . . relink, relink, relink, relink, relink. If you look up “tedious” in the dictionary, there’s a picture of the Scribus logo.
  • After more text-wrangling, it finally looked pretty presentable, so I decided to see how it would export to PDF. It turns out Scribus can’t embed OpenType fonts; so much for using Minion as the body text. Quick switch to Palatino.

In the end, the “booklet” didn’t look half bad for an hour and a half of experimentation, but I don’t think Scribus is quite ready for production work yet. Perhaps as a technical writer I’m spoiled by more sophisticated software like FrameMaker, which is geared toward long technical documents, whereas Scribus’ niche is more along the lines of PageMaker or QuarkXpress. It’s still missing features I would consider essential, such as numbered or bulleted lists, footnotes, cross-references, and indexing, in addition to more basic functionality like the aforementioned bold, italic, and right indent. I’m impressed with Scribus’ ability to create slick, spiral-bound, four-colour calendars. I’m less impressed with its ability to produce a short book, especially as it’s nearly six years old. But it definitely shows promise, and I can’t wait to see what future updates add.


2 Responses to I guess I’m just a masochist

  1. avox says:

    From your description it seems you are using 1.3.3.x (or even 1.2?). In 1.3.4 the following was added:
    – right margin
    – character styles
    – fonts are grouped by family, so it’s easier to switch between eg. “Times Regular”, “Times Bold” and “Times Italic”. Scribus does not try to generate faux bold or faux italic versions of a given fontface, seens that looks inferior and can make problem downstream.
    – OpenOffice import should keep all formatting, only MS Word import strips all formats
    – You can outline OTF fonts. Scribus doesn’t embed the fonts since embedding of OTF fonts is only supported since PDF 1.5. So for earlier PDF version it would be necessary to convert the fonts to TTF or CFF for embedding.

    We will release Scribus 1.3.5 soon and hope you’ll give that a try. It has many improvements, but easier text linking and better msaterpage support is still on the roadmap.


  2. Hi Andreas. Thanks for responding. You’re correct that I was using version 1.3.3 ( to be precise – the latest version my Ubuntu upgrades have delivered to me).

    Thank you for the tips; I’ll be sure to try some of your suggestions out. Lest I leave you with the impression that I wasn’t terribly pleased with Scribus, just keep in mind that this was my first time trying to do something with it and this post was intended to be a bit stream-of-consciousness. I think the software has some real promise, and I can’t wait to try out some more recent updates.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: